Iron Man came in 2008, which gave birth to the marvel cinematic universe that we now know and love. After much waiting and anticipation, the Avengers: Endgame is here. The ending has satisfied many; after all it grossed million dollars on the first day. There were moments in the movie that made us cry, laugh and smile.
The movie makers certainly didn’t fail to weave the multiple story arcs into a perfect conclusive story for the fans. Yet, the movie involved time travel so naturally there were some parts of it that didn’t make sense; leading to some loopholes.
After exploring that Avengers: Endgame ending, let’s talk about the loopholes we can’t figure out a solution for.
Nebula Killed Her Past Self, Wouldn’t That Have Killed Her Future Self Too?
A major problem in the movie occurs when 2014 Thanos gets hold of a 2023 Nebula (Karen Gillan) that has travelled back in time to Morag with Rhodes/War Machine (Don Cheadle) to get the Power Infinity Stone. Even though War Machine brings back the power stone, the 2023 Nebula is stuck with a 2014 Thanos, Gamora and Nebula. What’s worse is that Thanos sees the future unfold through the network in a 2014 Nebula’s brain. Moreover, he sends 2014 Nebula to go to the future which is the Avengers: Endgame present 2023. Then the still evil 2014 Nebula uses the time machine at the Avengers HQ to bring past Thanos, Gamora and his army into the future. And a crazy battle ensues.
Though, in the middle of it we see the 2023 Nebula convince 2014 Gamora to take her side and eventually kills her 2014 self.
Not only would this reverse the entire arc in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2, but it would also erase the 2023 version of Nebula. It’s the classic time travel grandfather paradox. If you go back in time to kill yourself, you wouldn’t be alive in the present. Essentially, Nebula can’t exist to kill herself. This loophole wasn’t given any explanation and probably won’t need to be resolved since Thanos is dead and the universe is restored to its natural state.
It shouldn’t matter since we got our happy ending, but it does make you scratch your head if you think too much on it.
How Come Spiderman and His Classmates Are Still In High school?
After that heartbreaking funeral scene of Tony Stark, we see that Spiderman aka Peter Parker (Tom Holland) reunites with his high school pal Ned (Jacob Batalon). Even though the real actors are aged above 20, the characters in the movie Spiderman: Homecoming were supposed to be 15. So, in Avengers: Infinity War Peter Parker and his friend Ned are about 16 or 17 at most.
When Thanos snapped his fingers in Avengers: Infinity War, Peter Parker disintegrated into dust. We know from the reunion that Ned did not. Five years went by until the events of Avengers: Endgame occurred where the Avengers team used time travel to capture all the stones and bring 50% of all human life back on earth.
5 years means Peter Parker and his friend had to be about 20 by now. Even if for some inexplicable physics related reason Peter Parker didn’t age, his friend Ned still should have. And he definitely should not have still been in high school. We know things didn’t go very well for the planet after the Thanos snap in 2018, but did it really mean that everyone would just be stuck in high school?
Captain America Living a Peaceful Life Would Have Messed up All The Timelines
Since this is also related to time travel, this will make your brain hurt like it did mine. So, brace yourselves. When Steve Rogers when back in time to return the Infinity Stones in their rightful places, he also took a little detour. That means he went ahead and lived a peaceful life with Peggy Carter.
Now, as discussed previously, this is a bit problematic. Not that we have anything against Captain America living a peaceful life, we’re actually quite happy for him. It’s just that from a time travel point of view, it makes no sense. You see when Steve Rogers went back in time, he creates a new timeline for himself. Yet, it doesn’t make sense when he returns to 2023 as an old man to the surprise of Sam Wilson, Bucky Barnes and The Hulk.
There’s a theory that the only way it could have been possible is that every timeline always has two Steve Rogers in it. Though, does that mean Peggy Carter always keeps one Steve Roger a secret from the other? And how do both Steve Rogers never accidentally bump into each other like they did in Avengers: Endgame. Do they somehow have a secret meeting about it and agree to it? It’s all kind of muddled up at this point.
Thanks to comments down below, we’re given another theory over it. The alternative way would be if he had some sort of device to travel back from a different timeline to this one. But how did Captain America manage to return all the infinity stones in and still lead a different life in a different time life and then return to this original one?
Loki May Have Created a New Timeline For Himself As Well
As the team of 2023 Avengers make their way back into the past in teams of three, we see Tony Stark, Captain America and the Hulk make their way to 2012 where they give Tony an arc reactor failure when he meets Secretary Pierce. This gives them the opportunity to remove the Tesseract briefcase containing the Space Stone. Though, the angry and uncontrollable Hulk of 2012 makes matters worse which leads to the Space Stone getting into the hands of Loki. 2012 Loki, being 2012 Loki, uses it to escape into a possibly new timeline he creates for himself.
This is complicated because Loki escapes the eventual Battle of New York in that 2012 reality. Plus, given the fact that he’s still working for Thanos at that moment in time, he would have just handed that Space Stone to Thanos in 2012. That means the events of Thor: The Dark World did not take place. This would further change the timelines as Asgard may not be destroyed and Thor would still have his trusty Mjnolnir. Consequently, the events that lead to Avengers having a civil war amongst them wouldn’t have happened either. So, what does it all mean?
Moral of the story: Time travel will make your brain hurt if you think about it too much in any movie ever. Avengers: Endgame still manages to satisfy us with its ending if you don’t ponder over the details too much. And that’s okay. No one’s complaining.